CurbScoop

4018 BROADWAY

Manhattan· Washington Heights· built 1910class D4BBL 1021260001
Open listing source

Your first look at this property

A free brief from the records below. Start here, then check the evidence.

Building overview

4018 BROADWAY is a 55-unit building in Washington Heights, Manhattan, built in 1910.

2 units are on the market here right now.

City records show 30 DOB permits and 71 violation records on file.

Units (res)
55
Floors
6.0
Lot ft²
17,670 ft²
Bldg ft²
84,102 ft²
Assessed
$3.21M
DOF FY2027 final roll
Deeds on this lot · 5 years
Unavailable
Excludes nearby comparable buildings

Official taxes & valuations

$7,128,000.00 · DOF market valueWhole tax lot · BBL 1021260001

FY2026–27 final assessment roll · Extract 2026-05-15

-12.6% change in DOF market value from the prior year.

Land value
$632,000.00
Building/improvement value
$6,496,000.00
Actual assessed value
$3,207,600.00
Assessed land
$284,400.00
Transitional assessed value
$3,245,318.00
Actual assessed-value exemptions
$61,740.00
Billable assessment before exemptions
$3,207,600.00
Billable assessed-value exemptions
$61,740.00
Taxable assessment after exemptions
$3,145,860.00
FY2025–26 DOF market value
$8,155,000.00
Prior-year actual assessed value
$3,669,750.00
Prior-year taxable assessment
$3,102,149.00

DOF values are used for property taxation. Condo and co-op tax valuations can differ substantially from sale prices. This is a tax-purpose estimate; comparable sales remain a separate valuation source. Roll exemptions can include STAR under DOF’s published layout.

These values cover the whole tax lot and do not value individual co-op shares.

Official DOF final assessment roll (ZIP) ↗
$392,203.36/yr · $32,683.61/mo equivalentWhole tax lot · BBL 1021260001

FY2026–27 · DOF statement 2026-08-15 · 4018 BROADWAY

The printed annual tax already deducts $6,790.00 in abatements and/or STAR.

Billable assessment on this statement
$3,207,600.00
Tax rate on this statement
12.4390%
Annual tax before abatements/STAR
$398,993.36
Monthly equivalent before abatements/STAR
$33,249.45

The before-abatement amount adds the printed deduction back to the annual tax, holding the assessment and rate unchanged. It does not predict benefit expiration, future taxes or a buyer’s eligibility.

DOF tax-purpose market value on this statement: $7,128,000.00.

Named benefits on the statement
Basic Star - School Tax Relief 6 units $1,614.00
Enhanced Star - School Tax Relief 8 units $5,176.00

This covers the whole tax lot. Co-op building taxes cannot be added to an apartment’s maintenance or divided among its units.

Read official DOF tax bill ↗
How we calculate your annual taxes:
Billable assessed value: $3,207,600.00
times the current tax rate: x 12.4390%
minus abatements and/or STAR: – $6,790.00
Annual property tax: $392,203.36

HOA, common charges and maintenance require documented building or unit evidence. Sales and DOB records do not establish these amounts. A zero property-tax bill does not establish zero PILOT or other ownership charges. Bills may change with tax rates or benefits; monthly figures are annual equivalents.

Look up this tax lot at DOF ↗

Public building financial filings

NY Attorney General offering plans and amendments can document budgets, financial statements, reserves and sponsor obligations. These records cover the development, including properties without active listings.

No exact offering-plan match has been collected here yet. Eligible condo and co-op properties are queued when viewed. Missing filings do not establish zero fees, assessments or debt.

Search the official NYAG offering-plan database ↗

Tax-benefit schedules, statement balances, penalties and declared capital work cover the identified tax lot. Condo billing-lot evidence is shown separately from apartment evidence.

DOF published abatements & termsTax lot 1021260001

Tax benefits & expiration

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
COOP · Published benefit begin date
Evidence

{"actabtpcyc": "0.00", "actabtpyr": "0.00", "appliedabt": "0.00", "appseq": "23", "appstat": "D", "caseno": "3146", "extractdt": "2026-08-15T00:00:00.000", "parid": "1021260001", "period": "2Q", "rate_pct": "0.001750", "taxyr": "2027", "tccode": "COOP", "yearabtpct": "0.000000", "yrbegdt": "1996-07-01T00:00:00.000"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
1996-07-01As of 2026-08-15
FY2027 2Q
Published schedule · exact tax lot
COOP · source eligibility / application status
Evidence

{"actabtpcyc": "0.00", "actabtpyr": "0.00", "appliedabt": "0.00", "appseq": "23", "appstat": "D", "caseno": "3146", "extractdt": "2026-08-15T00:00:00.000", "parid": "1021260001", "period": "2Q", "rate_pct": "0.001750", "taxyr": "2027", "tccode": "COOP", "yearabtpct": "0.000000", "yrbegdt": "1996-07-01T00:00:00.000"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
appstat=DAs of 2026-08-15
FY2027 2Q
Source reported · exact tax lot

FY2027 2Q source abatement terms, dated 2026-08-15. Dates and amounts do not guarantee eligibility after purchase. Per-cycle amounts are not annualized; overlapping calculations are not summed.

Published benefit amounts and dates do not guarantee eligibility after a purchase. An end date alone does not establish the future tax bill; assessment, tax rate and other benefits may change.

Source updated 2026-10-05 · collected 2026-10-09.

Open official source ↗
DOF final assessed-value exemptionsTax lot 1021260001

Tax benefits & expiration

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
WOODROW COURT INC · Final actual exempt assessed value
Evidence

{"benftstart": "+0000", "bldg_class": "D4", "block": "2126", "boro": "1", "exmp_code": "1010", "exmp_code_suffix": "10101", "exmp_seq": "12", "exname": "WOODROW COURT INC", "extractdt": "20260515", "finexmptot": "0", "finexmptrn": "0", "finexmptxbl": "0", "fintaxclass": "2", "lot": "1", "no_years": "0", "nys_exmp_code": "41136", "parid": "1021260001", "period": "3", "pstatus": "A", "rectype": "1", "status": "A", "year": "2027"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-05-15
FY2027 final roll
Source reported · exact tax lot
WOODROW COURT INC · Final exempt assessed value used for billing
Evidence

{"benftstart": "+0000", "bldg_class": "D4", "block": "2126", "boro": "1", "exmp_code": "1010", "exmp_code_suffix": "10101", "exmp_seq": "12", "exname": "WOODROW COURT INC", "extractdt": "20260515", "finexmptot": "0", "finexmptrn": "0", "finexmptxbl": "0", "fintaxclass": "2", "lot": "1", "no_years": "0", "nys_exmp_code": "41136", "parid": "1021260001", "period": "3", "pstatus": "A", "rectype": "1", "status": "A", "year": "2027"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-05-15
FY2027 final roll
Source reported · exact tax lot

Final exemption values reduce assessed value; they are not cash savings or annual taxes. No expiration date inferred from a start year or duration.

Published benefit amounts and dates do not guarantee eligibility after a purchase. An end date alone does not establish the future tax bill; assessment, tax rate and other benefits may change.

Source updated 2026-09-15 · collected 2026-10-09.

Open official source ↗
DOF statement balancesTax lot 1021260001

Public balances & charges

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
Outstanding charges
Evidence

Outstanding charges $0.00

Separate dated balance; do not add to annual costs

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot
New charges this billing period
Evidence

New charges $109,097.66

Separate dated balance; do not add to annual costs

Open official source ↗
$109,097.66As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot
Statement amount due
Evidence

Amount Due 10/01/26: $109,097.66

Separate dated balance; do not add to annual costs

Due date: 2026-10-01

Open official source ↗
$109,097.66As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot
Department of Finance Total
Evidence

Department of Finance Total $109,097.66

May be in statement balance; do not add twice

Open official source ↗
$109,097.66As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot
Department of Buildings Total
Evidence

Department of Buildings Total $0.00

May be in statement balance; do not add twice

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot
Fire Department Total
Evidence

Fire Department Total $0.00

May be in statement balance; do not add twice

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot
Department of Housing Preservation and Development Total
Evidence

Department of Housing Preservation and Development Total $0.00

May be in statement balance; do not add twice

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot
Tax Commission Total
Evidence

Tax Commission Total $0.00

May be in statement balance; do not add twice

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot

Source updated 2026-08-15 · collected 2026-10-11.

Open official source ↗
DOB energy disclosureTax lot 1021260001

Penalties, energy & capital work

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
LL84 reported location-based emissions
Evidence

{"property_id": "26634249", "year_ending": "2024-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1021260001", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "620.78", "property_gfa_self_reported": "89990"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
620.78 tonnes CO2e2024
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported gross floor area
Evidence

{"property_id": "26634249", "year_ending": "2024-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1021260001", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "620.78", "property_gfa_self_reported": "89990"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
89,990 ft²2024
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported location-based emissions
Evidence

{"property_id": "55753194", "year_ending": "2024-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1021260001", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": null, "total_location_based_ghg": "620.89", "property_gfa_self_reported": "89989"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
620.89 tonnes CO2e2024
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported gross floor area
Evidence

{"property_id": "55753194", "year_ending": "2024-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1021260001", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": null, "total_location_based_ghg": "620.89", "property_gfa_self_reported": "89989"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
89,989 ft²2024
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported location-based emissions
Evidence

{"property_id": "26634249", "year_ending": "2023-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1021260001", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "596", "property_gfa_self_reported": "89990"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
596 tonnes CO2e2023
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported gross floor area
Evidence

{"property_id": "26634249", "year_ending": "2023-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1021260001", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "596", "property_gfa_self_reported": "89990"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
89,990 ft²2023
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported location-based emissions
Evidence

{"property_id": "26634249", "year_ending": "2022-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1021260001", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "576.5", "property_gfa_self_reported": "89990"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
576.5 tonnes CO2e2022
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported gross floor area
Evidence

{"property_id": "26634249", "year_ending": "2022-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1021260001", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "576.5", "property_gfa_self_reported": "89990"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
89,990 ft²2022
Historical actual · reported property / campus

Complete published 2022–2024 LL84 dataset. Reported property/campus scope can include several buildings and lots; these are not LL97 issued fines.

Reported energy figures may cover several buildings or lots. They are not verified LL97 emissions, a penalty calculation, or this apartment’s utility bill.

Source updated 2025-11-25 · collected 2026-10-09.

Open official source ↗
DOB declared construction workTax lot 1021260001

Penalties, energy & capital work

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
Declared construction estimate · M01275638-I1-GC#1
Evidence

interior renovation limited to enlargement of existing bathroom to relocate lavatory and kitchen renovation by replacement of kitchen cabinets and appliances. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$10,000.00As of 2025-10-15
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01232742-I1-SG#1
Evidence

PROPOSED INSTALLATION OF 1 ILLUMINATED, NON FLASHING ACCESSORY BUSINESS SIGN. WORDING: LOGO AT&T

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$2,223.00As of 2025-06-11
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01040239-I1-MS#1
Evidence

Replace (2) 5-ton air handlers in existing equipment room on 1st floor. Replace related condensers on the roof. No change in use, egress, or occupancy.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$16,000.00As of 2024-07-05
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01045647-I1-SC#1
Evidence

Installation of suspended scaffold for facade work or inspection

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2024-05-21
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01045154-I1-SH#1
Evidence

Installation of a temporarily heavy-duty sidewalk shed per plan submitted. Work shall comply with 2022 building codes chapter 33. No change in use, egress and/or occupancy with this application.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$5,000.00As of 2024-05-03
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M00989846-I1-ST#1
Evidence

selective repair of brick replacement, repointing , stonework ,lintel and sill refurbishment

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$387,900.00As of 2024-01-25
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M00749369-I1-GC#1
Evidence

ALT1 FILED TO CREATE LAUNDRY AND COMMUNITY ROOMS IN BASEMENT AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$320,000.00As of 2022-11-16
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M00749321-I1-MS#1
Evidence

INSTALLATION OF VENTILATION SYSTEM FOR NEW DRYERS AND ASSOCIATED DUCK WORK AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS, OR OCCUPANCY.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$21,000.00As of 2022-09-14
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M00749472-I1-PL#1
Evidence

PLUMBING WORK FOR NEW LAUNDRY ROOM AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS, OR OCCUPANCY.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$18,000.00As of 2022-09-14
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M00713746-I1-AN#1
Evidence

Dish - Installation of new antenna sectors, GPS antenna and equipment cabinet on the roof. Installation of conduits and service room connection as per plans. All work is in compliance with 5/98.No change in use, egress or occupancy.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$37,500.00As of 2022-08-23
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M00709885-I1-AN#1
Evidence

VERIZON SITE MODIFICATIONS TO INCLUDE THE REPLACEMENT OF (8) EXISTING ANTENNAS AND (9) EXISTING RRH UNITS. ALL IN CONFORMANCE WITH TPPN #5/98.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$18,700.00As of 2022-07-28
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M00601821-I1-PL#1
Evidence

ALL CONSTRUCTION WORK IS FILED UNDER DOBNOW# M00601705-I1. INSTALLATION OF 6 PLUMBING FIXTURES, AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS, OR OCCUPANCY.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$15,000.00As of 2021-12-03
Declared estimate · exact tax lot

Up to 30 most recent distinct filings from the past five years; this is not a complete capital-work inventory.

Declared job estimates are not actual spending or approved assessments. Repeated permit rows for the same filing are counted once; separate job filings may still describe related work.

Source publication date not provided.

Open official source ↗
Model annual LL97 emissions exposure

Enter verified LL97 emissions and the applicable annual limit. LL84 location-based emissions above are a different reported metric and are not automatically used here.

Enter both assumptions to calculate exposure.

Before exemptions, adjustments, offsets or penalty mitigation. This scenario does not establish an issued fine or an apartment charge.

Official DOB penalty guidance ↗

Active sale listings (2)

AddressNeighborhoodPrice$/ft²SqftBeds/Bathsvs compDOMRiskScore
565 WEST 169 STREET #2J
Manhattan · built 1910
Washington Heights$395K-0 ft²1 bd · 1 ba-87
6 HPD-C7 DOBbedbug
20.2Source
565 WEST 169 STREET #6F
Manhattan · built 1910
Washington Heights$800K-0 ft²2 bd · 1 ba-4
6 HPD-C7 DOBbedbug
20.2Source

Building activity

Open a record to read the full agency text.

Housing violations (HPD) 40

Housing violationClass BJun 30, 2022Violation dismissed

§ 27-2005, 2007 ADM CODE REMOVE ALL ENCUMBRANCES CONSISTING OF CONSISTING OF HOUSEHOLD ITEMS AT PUBLIC HALL, 4th STORY

HPD record 15252099
Housing violationClass BJun 30, 2022Violation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE PROPERLY REPAIR WITH SIMILAR MATERIAL THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE FIRE RETARDANT MATERIAL AT CEILING AND SOUTH WALL AT BULKHEAD

HPD record 15252094
Housing violationClass BJun 30, 2022Violation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE ROOF SO THAT IT WILL NOT LEAK AT CEILING AT BULKHEAD

HPD record 15252087
Show 37 more records
Heating recordClass CJun 30, 2022Violation dismissed

§ 27-2033 ADM CODE POST NOTICE, IN FORM APPROVED BY THE DEPARTMENT, STATING THE NAME AND LOCATION OF THE PERSON DESIGNATED BY THE OWNER TO HAVE KEY TO BUILDINGS HEATING SYSTEM MISSING AT PUBLIC HALL, 1st STORY

HPD record 15252078
Housing violationClass AJun 30, 2022Violation dismissed

§ 27-2053 ADM CODE POST SIGN ON WALL OF ENTRANCE STORY BEARING NAME, ADDRESS INCLUDING APARTMENT NUMBER IF ANY, AND TELEPHONE NUMBER OF SUPERINTENDENT, JANITOR OR HOUSEKEEPER. AT PUBLIC HALL, 1st STORY

HPD record 15252079
Housing violationClass AJun 30, 2022Violation dismissed

§ 27-2005 HMC: POST, IN A FORM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSIONER, AND MAINTAIN A NOTICE IN A COMMON AREA OF THE BUILDING REGARDING THE PROCEDURES THAT SHOULD BE FOLLOWED WHEN A GAS LEAK IS SUSPECTED

HPD record 15252082
Housing violationClass AJun 30, 2022Violation dismissed

§ 27-2013 ADM CODE PAINT WITH LIGHT COLORED PAINT TO THE SATISFACTION OF THIS DEPARTMENT AT CEILING AND SOUTH WALL AT BULKHEAD

HPD record 15252095
Housing violationClass CJun 23, 2022Violation dismissed

§ 27-2005, 27-2007, 27-2041.1 HMC: REPLACE OR REPAIR THE SELF-CLOSING DOORS THAT IS MISSING OR DEFECTIVE AT SOUTH SECTION BULKHEAD

HPD record 15233664
Housing violationClass AJan 22, 2021 · Apt 4BViolation closed

§ 300 M/D LAW FILE PLANS AND APPLICATION AND LEGALIZE THE FOLLOWING ALTERATION OR RESTORE TO THE LEGAL CONDITION EXISTING PRIOR TO THE MAKING OF SAID ALTERATION WOOD PANELLING AT ALL WALLS IN THE 4th ROOM FROM NORTH AT WEST LOCATED AT APT 4B, 4th STORY, APARTMENT AT EAST , SECTION AT SOUTH

HPD record 14001544
Housing violationClass AJan 22, 2021 · Apt 4BViolation closed

§ 300 M/D LAW FILE PLANS AND APPLICATION AND LEGALIZE THE FOLLOWING ALTERATION OR RESTORE TO THE LEGAL CONDITION EXISTING PRIOR TO THE MAKING OF SAID ALTERATION WOOD PANELLING ON ALL WALLS IN THE 4th ROOM FROM NORTH AT EAST LOCATED AT APT 4B, 4th STORY, APARTMENT AT EAST , SECTION AT SOUTH

HPD record 14001522
Housing violationClass AJan 22, 2021 · Apt 4BViolation closed

§ 300 M/D LAW FILE PLANS AND APPLICATION AND LEGALIZE THE FOLLOWING ALTERATION OR RESTORE TO THE LEGAL CONDITION EXISTING PRIOR TO THE MAKING OF SAID ALTERATION WOOD PANELLING ON ALL WALLS IN THE FOYER LOCATED AT APT 4B, 4th STORY, APARTMENT AT EAST , SECTION AT SOUTH

HPD record 14001520
Housing violationClass AJan 22, 2021 · Apt 4BViolation closed

§ 300 M/D LAW FILE PLANS AND APPLICATION AND LEGALIZE THE FOLLOWING ALTERATION OR RESTORE TO THE LEGAL CONDITION EXISTING PRIOR TO THE MAKING OF SAID ALTERATION ACCOUSTIC CEILING TILES IN THE 4th ROOM FROM NORTH AT EAST LOCATED AT APT 4B, 4th STORY, APARTMENT AT EAST , SECTION AT SOUTH

HPD record 14001542
Housing violationClass AJan 22, 2021 · Apt 4BViolation closed

§ 300 M/D LAW FILE PLANS AND APPLICATION AND LEGALIZE THE FOLLOWING ALTERATION OR RESTORE TO THE LEGAL CONDITION EXISTING PRIOR TO THE MAKING OF SAID ALTERATION ACCOUSTIC CEILING PANEL IN THE FOYER LOCATED AT APT 4B, 4th STORY, APARTMENT AT EAST , SECTION AT SOUTH

HPD record 14001519
Housing violationClass AJan 22, 2021 · Apt 4BViolation closed

§ 300 M/D LAW FILE PLANS AND APPLICATION AND LEGALIZE THE FOLLOWING ALTERATION OR RESTORE TO THE LEGAL CONDITION EXISTING PRIOR TO THE MAKING OF SAID ALTERATION WOOD PANELING ON ALL WALLS IN THE KITCHEN LOCATED AT APT 4B, 4th STORY, APARTMENT AT EAST , SECTION AT SOUTH

HPD record 14001517
Housing violationClass CJan 22, 2021 · Apt 1IViolation closed

§ 27-2005, 27-2007, 27-2041.1 HMC: REPLACE OR REPAIR THE SELF-CLOSING DOORS THAT IS MISSING OR DEFECTIVE , IN THE ENTRANCE LOCATED AT APT 1I, 1st STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM NORTH AT EAST , SECTION AT NORTH

HPD record 14001579
Housing violationClass CJan 22, 2021 · Apt 6CViolation closed

§ 27-2005, 2007 ADM CODE ARRANGE AND MAKE SELF-CLOSING THE DOORS , IN THE ENTRANCE LOCATED AT APT 6C, 6th STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM SOUTH AT WEST , SECTION AT SOUTH

HPD record 14001567
Housing violationClass AJan 22, 2021 · Apt 4BViolation closed

§ 300 M/D LAW FILE PLANS AND APPLICATION AND LEGALIZE THE FOLLOWING ALTERATION OR RESTORE TO THE LEGAL CONDITION EXISTING PRIOR TO THE MAKING OF SAID ALTERATION ACCOUSTIC CEILING TILES IN THE 4th ROOM FROM NORTH AT WEST LOCATED AT APT 4B, 4th STORY, APARTMENT AT EAST , SECTION AT SOUTH

HPD record 14001547
Housing violationClass BJan 15, 2021Violation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE PROPERLY REPAIR WITH SIMILAR MATERIAL THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE FIRE RETARDANT MATERIAL AT CEILING AND NORTH WALL AT PUBLIC HALL, 1st STORY

HPD record 13989816
Housing violationClass AJan 15, 2021Violation closed

§ 27-2013 ADM CODE PAINT WITH LIGHT COLORED PAINT TO THE SATISFACTION OF THIS DEPARTMENT AT CEILING AND NORTH WALL AT PUBLIC HALL, 1st STORY

HPD record 13989819
Housing violationClass AJun 8, 2018Violation closed

§ 27-2013 ADM CODE PAINT WITH LIGHT COLORED PAINT TO THE SATISFACTION OF THIS DEPARTMENT WALLS AND CEILING AT NORTH AND SOUTH ROOF BULKHEAD

HPD record 12425094
Housing violationClass CJun 8, 2018Violation closed

§ 27-2043.1 HMC INSTALL THE MISSING OR REPAIR/REPLACE THE DEFECTIVE WINDOW GUARD(S) THROUGHOUT THE PUBLIC AREAS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE SPECIFICATIONS OF THE NEW YORK CITY HEALTH CODE SECTION 24 RCNY CHAPTER 12.

HPD record 12423328
Housing violationClass BJun 8, 2018Violation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE PROPERLY REPAIR WITH SIMILAR MATERIAL THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE FIRE RETARDANT MATERIAL AT WALLS AND CEILING AT NORTH AND SOUTH ROOF BULKHEAD

HPD record 12425092
Housing violationClass BJun 8, 2018Violation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE PROVIDE STEEL GATE UNDER SKYLIGHT AT NORTH AND EAST ROOF BULKHEAD

HPD record 12425090
Housing violationClass CJun 14, 2012 · Apt 2GNov sent out

§ 27-2056.7 ADM CODE -CORRECT FAILURE TO PROVIDE TO THE DEPARTMENT WITHIN 45 DAYS OF DEMAND ALL RECORDS REQUIRED TO BE MAINTAINED BY OWNER

HPD record 9520833
Housing violationClass BSep 25, 2006 · Apt 1IViolation closed

§ 27-2005, 27-2007, 27-2041.1 HMC: REPLACE OR REPAIR THE SELF-CLOSING DOORS THAT IS MISSING OR DEFECTIVE .. IN THE ENTRANCE LOCATED AT APT 1I, 1st STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM NORTH AT EAST

HPD record 6390433
Housing violationClass ANov 13, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REFIT DOOR ENTRANCE KITCHEN 5 STY APT 5F LOCATED AT APT 5F

HPD record 2828508
Housing violationClass ANov 13, 1996Violation dismissed

§ 27-2013 ADM CODE PAINT WITH LIGHT COLORED PAINT TO THE SATISFACTION OF THIS DEPARTMENT CEILING & WALLS EAST WATERCLOSET

HPD record 2828507
Housing violationClass ANov 13, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR WARPED WALL CABINET KITCHEN 5 STY APT 5F LOCATED AT APT 5F

HPD record 2828506
Housing violationClass BNov 13, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPLACE WITH NEW THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE BASEBOARD FLOOR CABINET SINK KITCHEN 5 STY APT 5F LOCATED AT APT 5F

HPD record 2828505
Housing violationClass BNov 13, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE PROPERLY REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE WALLS CABINET KITCHEN 5 STY APT 5F LOCATED AT APT 5F

HPD record 2828504
Housing violationClass BNov 13, 1996Violation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR WALLS KITCHEN 5 STY PAT 5F

HPD record 2828503
Housing violationClass ANov 13, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPLACE WITH NEW THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE CEILING MOLDING SOUTHWEST ROOM 5 STY APT 5F LOCATED AT APT 5F

HPD record 2828502
Housing violationClass ANov 13, 1996Violation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE PAINT METAL IN ACCORDANCE WITH DEPT. REGULATION STEAM RISERS THRU OUT 5 STY APT 5F

HPD record 2828509
Housing violationClass BApr 5, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR CEILING NORTH ROOM 5 STY 2 FROM SOUTH AT WEST APT 5F. , SECTION '' ''

HPD record 2828501
Housing violationClass BApr 5, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE & 309 M/D LAW ABATE THE NUISANCE CONSISTING OF CONCEALED LEAK WALLS BATHROOM 5 STY 2 FROM SOUTH AT WEST APT 5F. , SECTION '' ''

HPD record 2828492
Housing violationClass BApr 5, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR WALLS AND CEILING BATHROOM 5 STY 2 FROM SOUTH AT WEST APT 5F. , SECTION '' ''

HPD record 2828493
Housing violationClass AApr 5, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPLACE WITH NEW THE MISSING CERAMIC TILE WALLS BATHROOM 5 STY 2 FROM SOUTH AT WEST APT 5F. , SECTION '' ''

HPD record 2828494
Housing violationClass BApr 5, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE & 309 M/D LAW ABATE THE NUISANCE CONSISTING OF CONCEALED LEAK WALLS KITCHEN NEAR SINK 5 STY 2 FROM SOUTH AT WEST APT 5F. , SECTION '' ''

HPD record 2828495
Housing violationClass BApr 5, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR WALLS KITCHEN 5 STY 2 FROM SOUTH AT WEST APT 5F. , SECTION '' ''

HPD record 2828496
Housing violationClass BApr 5, 1996 · Apt 5FViolation closed

§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR WALLS AND CEILING NORTHEAST ROOM 5 STY 2 FROM SOUTH AT WEST APT 5F. , SECTION '' ''

HPD record 2828497

Latest 40 records shown.

Work permits (DOB) 30

General ConstructionOct 15, 2025Permit issued

interior renovation limited to enlargement of existing bathroom to relocate lavatory and kitchen renovation by replacement of kitchen cabinets and appliances. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

AM GROUP 2000 CROP

Issued Oct 21, 2025

DOB filing M01275638-I1-GC#1
General ConstructionOct 15, 2025Permit issued

interior renovation limited to enlargement of existing bathroom to relocate lavatory and kitchen renovation by replacement of kitchen cabinets and appliances. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

AM GROUP 2000 CROP

Issued Oct 28, 2025

DOB filing M01275638-I1-GC#2
SignJun 11, 2025Signed-off

PROPOSED INSTALLATION OF 1 ILLUMINATED, NON FLASHING ACCESSORY BUSINESS SIGN. WORDING: LOGO AT&T

UNITECH DESIGN INC

Issued Jun 11, 2025

DOB filing M01232742-I1-SG#1
Show 27 more records
Mechanical SystemsJul 5, 2024Permit issued

Replace (2) 5-ton air handlers in existing equipment room on 1st floor. Replace related condensers on the roof. No change in use, egress, or occupancy.

WESTROCK MECHANICAL CORP

Issued Sep 26, 2024

DOB filing M01040239-I1-MS#1
Suspended ScaffoldMay 21, 2024Signed-off

Installation of suspended scaffold for facade work or inspection

Issued May 21, 2024

DOB filing M01045647-I1-SC#1
Sidewalk ShedMay 3, 2024Signed-off

Installation of a temporarily heavy-duty sidewalk shed per plan submitted. Work shall comply with 2022 building codes chapter 33. No change in use, egress and/or occupancy with this application.

ANDAMIO SCAFFOLDING LLC

Issued May 3, 2024

DOB filing M01045154-I1-SH#1
StructuralJan 25, 2024Signed-off

selective repair of brick replacement, repointing , stonework ,lintel and sill refurbishment

LAWRENCE EXTERIOR RESTORA

Issued May 30, 2024

DOB filing M00989846-I1-ST#1
General ConstructionNov 16, 2022Permit issued

ALT1 FILED TO CREATE LAUNDRY AND COMMUNITY ROOMS IN BASEMENT AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH.

PMN INTERIOR CORPORATION

Issued Feb 1, 2023

DOB filing M00749369-I1-GC#1
PlumbingSep 14, 2022Signed-off

PLUMBING WORK FOR NEW LAUNDRY ROOM AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS, OR OCCUPANCY.

ORBIT PLBG & HTG INC

Issued Feb 14, 2023

DOB filing M00749472-I1-PL#1
Mechanical SystemsSep 14, 2022Signed-off

INSTALLATION OF VENTILATION SYSTEM FOR NEW DRYERS AND ASSOCIATED DUCK WORK AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS, OR OCCUPANCY.

PMN INTERIOR CORPORATION

Issued Feb 2, 2023

DOB filing M00749321-I1-MS#1
AntennaAug 23, 2022Signed-off

Dish - Installation of new antenna sectors, GPS antenna and equipment cabinet on the roof. Installation of conduits and service room connection as per plans. All work is in compliance with 5/98.No change in use, egress or occupancy.

ONE TIME ONLY INC

Issued Sep 29, 2022

DOB filing M00713746-I1-AN#1
AntennaJul 28, 2022Permit issued

VERIZON SITE MODIFICATIONS TO INCLUDE THE REPLACEMENT OF (8) EXISTING ANTENNAS AND (9) EXISTING RRH UNITS. ALL IN CONFORMANCE WITH TPPN #5/98.

E.T. VANDERBECK INC

Issued Aug 15, 2022

DOB filing M00709885-I1-AN#1
AntennaJul 28, 2022Permit issued

VERIZON SITE MODIFICATIONS TO INCLUDE THE REPLACEMENT OF (8) EXISTING ANTENNAS AND (9) EXISTING RRH UNITS. ALL IN CONFORMANCE WITH TPPN #5/98.

RAMAPO COMMUNICATION CORP

Issued Jun 1, 2023

DOB filing M00709885-I1-AN#2
PlumbingDec 3, 2021Signed-off

ALL CONSTRUCTION WORK IS FILED UNDER DOBNOW# M00601705-I1. INSTALLATION OF 6 PLUMBING FIXTURES, AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS, OR OCCUPANCY.

CROSSFIELD P & H CORP

Issued Jan 6, 2022

DOB filing M00601821-I1-PL#1
General ConstructionOct 19, 2021Permit issued

INTERIOR RENOVATION OF JUICE BAR, NEW STOREFRONT, INTERIOR PARTITIONS, FLOORING AND LIGHT FIXTURES, AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.

AL SAEED CONSTRUCTION

Issued Dec 2, 2021

DOB filing M00601705-I1-GC#1
General ConstructionJan 27, 2021Signed-off

INSTALL STOREFRONT AWNING WITH NON-ILLUMINATED COPY READING METRO BY T MOBILE. COPY NOT TO EXCEED 12 SQ FT TOTAL. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

CAPITOL AWNING CO INC

Issued Feb 12, 2021

DOB filing M00457327-I1-GC#1
AntennaNov 14, 2019Signed-off

AT&T - Installation of new antenna sectors with related appurtenances on roof. Installation of new cabinets on equipment platform on roof. Platform filed under separate application. All work is in compliance with TPPN 5/98. No change to occupancy, use, or egress.

JACOBS TELECOMMUN. INC

Issued Feb 27, 2020

DOB filing M00164629-I1-AN#2
AntennaNov 14, 2019Signed-off

AT&T - Installation of new antenna sectors with related appurtenances on roof. Installation of new cabinets on equipment platform on roof. Platform filed under separate application. All work is in compliance with TPPN 5/98. No change to occupancy, use, or egress.

JACOBS TELECOMMUN. INC

Issued Nov 15, 2019

DOB filing M00164629-I1-AN#1
Sidewalk ShedJun 4, 2019Signed-off

INSTALLATION OF SIDEWALK SHED AS PER PLANS. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.

EVEREST SCAFFOLDING INC

Issued Jun 4, 2019

DOB filing M00173528-I1-SH#1
Supported ScaffoldMay 29, 2019Permit issued

INSTALLATION OF PIPE SCAFFOLD AS PER PLANS. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.

LAWRENCE EXTERIOR RESTORA

Issued May 29, 2019

DOB filing M00166664-I1-SF#1
OTOct 31, 1996Issued

OT

CW BROWN,INC.NTERIORS,INC.

Issued Oct 31, 1996

DOB filing 8335
PLOct 25, 1993Issued

A2

DANIEL WEINTRAUB

Issued Oct 26, 1993

DOB filing 374940
OTNov 20, 1991Issued

OT

PEROTTO ASSOCIATES

Issued Nov 20, 1991

DOB filing 189574
OTFiling date not suppliedIssued

OT

PREMIER REMODELING CONTRA

DOB filing 2124201
OTFiling date not suppliedIssued

OT

INTEGRATED CONSTRUCTION SERVICES

DOB filing 2017972
EQFiling date not suppliedIssued

SH

ROCKLEDGE SCAFFOLD

DOB filing 2000494
PLFiling date not suppliedIssued

A2

R A HEAT CONTR CO

DOB filing 1522899
FPFiling date not suppliedIssued

FP

NY FIRE LLC

DOB filing 2697233
OTFiling date not suppliedIssued

OT

IN HOUSE CONSTRUCTION

DOB filing 1579277
MHFiling date not suppliedIssued

MH

STANMARK CORP

DOB filing 3135810

Latest 30 records shown.

Building violations (DOB) 31

BENCH-FAILURE TO BENCHMARK NONEMay 3, 2023Disposition recorded Jun 29, 2023

FAILURE TO FILE BENCHMARKING REPORT OF ENERGY USE AS PER AD. CODE SEC. 28-309.4

DOB record 2641621
EARCX-FAILURE TO SUBMIT EER NONEJun 20, 2021Disposition recorded Aug 13, 2021

FAILURE TO SUBMIT AN EER PER AD. CODE SEC. 28-308.4 - MULTIPLE YEARS (2020)

DOB record 2530778
EARCX-FAILURE TO SUBMIT EER NONEJun 29, 2020Disposition recorded Aug 13, 2021

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 2465017
Show 28 more records
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDDec 18, 2019Disposition recorded Dec 16, 2022

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 2431321
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDDec 18, 2019Disposition recorded Dec 16, 2022

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 2431312
EARCX-FAILURE TO SUBMIT EER NONEMar 18, 2019No disposition date supplied

FAILURE TO SUBMIT AN EER PER AD. CODE SEC. 28-308.4 - MULTIPLE YEARS (2018)

DOB record 2333633
EARCX-FAILURE TO SUBMIT EER NONEMar 17, 2019No disposition date supplied

FAILURE TO SUBMIT AN EER PER AD. CODE SEC. 28-308.4 - MULTIPLE YEARS (2017)

DOB record 2332757
EARCX-FAILURE TO SUBMIT EER NONEMar 16, 2019No disposition date supplied

FAILURE TO SUBMIT AN EER PER AD. CODE SEC. 28-308.4 IN 2016

DOB record 2332585
LBLVIO-LOW PRESSURE BOILER BOILER REQUIREDFeb 24, 2017No disposition date supplied

VIOLATION ISSUED FOR FAILURE TO FILE ANNUAL BOILER 2015 INSPECTION REPORT

DOB record 2147252
ACC1-(OTHER BLDGS TYPES) - ELEVATOR AFFIRMATION OF CORRECTION ELEVATORREQUIREDJan 3, 2017Disposition recorded Aug 28, 2017

VIO ISSUED TO ELEVATOR - FAIL TO CORRECT DEFECTS ON 2015 CAT 1 INSP/TST

DOB record 2127049
ACC1-(OTHER BLDGS TYPES) - ELEVATOR AFFIRMATION OF CORRECTION ELEVATORREQUIREDMay 30, 2014No disposition date supplied

VIO ISSUED TO ELEVATOR - FAIL TO CORRECT DEFECTS ON 2012 CAT 1 INSP/TST

DOB record 1879216
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDNov 21, 2013Disposition recorded Jul 8, 2014

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1296597
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDNov 21, 2013Disposition recorded Apr 2, 2014

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1295892
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDApr 11, 2012Disposition recorded Jun 6, 2013

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1674459
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDFeb 2, 2011No disposition date supplied

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1557201
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDFeb 2, 2011No disposition date supplied

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1557202
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDApr 15, 2010Disposition recorded Aug 28, 2012

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1465295
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDApr 15, 2010Disposition recorded Aug 28, 2012

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1465297
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDJan 26, 2009Disposition recorded Apr 14, 2010

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1494747
LL1198-LOCAL LAW 11/98 - FACADE FACADE OPTIONALNov 30, 2007Disposition recorded Jul 2, 2020

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1268764
L1198-LOCAL LAW 11/98 - FACADE FACADE REQUIREDJun 25, 2007Disposition recorded May 28, 2009

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 516570
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDOct 26, 2006Disposition recorded Feb 7, 2008

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1165320
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDOct 26, 2006Disposition recorded Mar 21, 2008

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1165321
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDMar 3, 2005Disposition recorded Aug 10, 2005

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1030082
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDMar 3, 2005Disposition recorded Aug 10, 2005

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1030080
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDFeb 16, 2004Disposition recorded Jun 3, 2004

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 110869
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDFeb 16, 2004Disposition recorded Aug 10, 2005

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 112711
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDDec 11, 2002Disposition recorded Apr 11, 2003

1P10855

DOB record 879342
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDApr 10, 1999Disposition recorded Mar 21, 2008

1P10855

DOB record 654593
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDApr 10, 1999Disposition recorded Mar 21, 2008

1P10856

DOB record 654594
B-BOILER BOILER OPTIONALMar 18, 1993Disposition recorded Jul 18, 1994

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 313465
Transaction history · 0 deeds

Recorded consideration. A $0 deed is not a sale price.

No recorded transactions for this BBL yet.

More buildings in Washington Heights

Sources, coverage & freshness

Sources & freshness

Research contract nyc_property_research.v1 · snapshot Nov 6, 2026

Stable property ID: nyc:bbl:1021260001

This identifier represents an NYC tax lot. Condo and co-op apartment identity must be resolved separately.

Tax lot and building facts

NYC Department of City Planning (PLUTO)

completed
1 tax-lot record in the current corpus · latest record Nov 1, 2026

Pipeline completed Nov 1, 2026

The current PLUTO pipeline is configured for Manhattan and Brooklyn.

PLUTO describes the tax lot and buildings, not legal ownership of an individual apartment.

Marketed sale listings

StreetEasy, observed by CurbScoop

completed
2 active sale listings in the current corpus · latest record Aug 27, 2026

Pipeline completed Aug 31, 2026

Retired source: collection stopped on 2026-08-31, so these are the last Manhattan and Brooklyn listings observed, not the current market.

Listing observations describe marketed state as of 2026-08-31 at the latest and are not proof of a closing or exhaustive market coverage.

Recorded transfers

NYC Department of Finance, Office of the City Register (ACRIS)

completed
0 recorded deeds in the current corpus

Pipeline completed Nov 6, 2026

Deed document types associated with this BBL in the current CurbScoop corpus.

Recording can lag a transaction, and a deed with no stated consideration is not evidence of a market sale.

DOB permits

NYC Department of Buildings via NYC Open Data

completed
135 permits in the current corpus · latest record Oct 28, 2025

Pipeline completed Nov 6, 2026

The current DOB permit pipeline is configured for Manhattan and Brooklyn.

A filing or permit does not prove that work was completed or that all work at the property was filed.

HPD violations

NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development via NYC Open Data

completed
67 violations in the current corpus · latest record Jan 16, 2026

Pipeline completed Nov 6, 2026

The current HPD violation pipeline is configured for Manhattan and Brooklyn.

Status and correction timing come from the published agency record and may change after CurbScoop observes it.

DOB violations

NYC Department of Buildings via NYC Open Data

completed
31 violations in the current corpus · latest record Jun 29, 2023

Pipeline completed Nov 6, 2026

The current DOB violation pipeline is configured for Manhattan and Brooklyn.

Absence from the current corpus is not proof that a building has no regulatory issue.

Counts and dates describe the current CurbScoop corpus. They are not a guarantee of exhaustive agency or listing coverage.

How to read these records

Deed amounts are recorded consideration, not asking prices or a unit valuation. A blank record is not proof that an issue does not exist.