CurbScoop
Menu
CurbScoop›Buildings›Carnegie Hill›1240 MADISON AVENUE

1240 MADISON AVENUE

Manhattan· Carnegie Hill· built 1925class D4BBL 1015010016
Open listing source

Your first look at this property

A free brief from the records below. Start here, then check the evidence.

Save this propertyOpen full research (1 credit)

Sign in to save, then confirm. Saving uses no credits.

What the records show

Risks & missing evidence

Building overview

1240 MADISON AVENUE is a 60-unit building in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan, built in 1925.

1 unit is on the market here right now.

City records show 30 DOB permits and 41 violation records on file.

Units (res)
60
Floors
12.0
Lot ft²
16,586 ft²
Bldg ft²
156,287 ft²
Assessed
$23.1M
DOF FY2027 final roll
Deeds on this lot · 5 years
Unavailable
Excludes nearby comparable buildings

Official taxes & valuations

19 published co-op apartment values · DOF supplemental roll

FY2027 · Published July 24, 2026 · Exact co-op tax lot 1015010016. These apartment values are separate from the ordinary whole-building assessment.

Showing 19 of 62 published apartment records. The official ZIP contains the complete source subset.

ApartmentPublished addressCo-op building / suffixDOF value
10A17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$1,117,638.00
10B17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$776,663.00
10C17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$909,265.00
10D17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$1,022,923.00
10E17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$625,119.00
11A17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$1,136,581.00
11B17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$814,550.00
11C17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$928,208.00
11D17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$1,041,866.00
11E17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$644,062.00
12A17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$1,155,524.00
12B17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$814,550.00
12C17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$947,151.00
12D17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$1,060,809.00
12E17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$681,948.00
13B17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$1,568,482.00
1A17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$132,601.00
1B17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$265,202.00
1C17 EAST 89 STREET1 / 0$598,599.00

DOF publishes individual values for selected co-op developments. Missing apartments remain unverified. A value on this roll is not a resale appraisal, a separate apartment tax bill, or proof that a surcharge is owed.

Official DOF supplemental roll (ZIP) ↗ · Official non-primary residence surcharge guidance ↗
$51,400,000.00 · DOF market valueWhole tax lot · BBL 1015010016

FY2026–27 final assessment roll · Extract 2026-05-15

+9.2% change in DOF market value from the prior year.

Land value
$6,380,000.00
Building/improvement value
$45,020,000.00
Actual assessed value
$23,130,000.00
Assessed land
$2,871,000.00
Transitional assessed value
$20,741,220.00
Actual assessed-value exemptions
$102,420.00
Billable assessment before exemptions
$20,741,220.00
Billable assessed-value exemptions
$102,420.00
Taxable assessment after exemptions
$20,638,800.00
FY2025–26 DOF market value
$47,064,000.00
Prior-year actual assessed value
$21,178,800.00
Prior-year taxable assessment
$20,121,190.00

DOF values are used for property taxation. Condo and co-op tax valuations can differ substantially from sale prices. This is a tax-purpose estimate; comparable sales remain a separate valuation source. Roll exemptions can include STAR under DOF’s published layout.

These values cover the whole tax lot and do not value individual co-op shares.

Official DOF final assessment roll (ZIP) ↗
$2,182,968.12/yr · $181,914.01/mo equivalentWhole tax lot · BBL 1015010016

FY2026–27 · DOF statement 2026-08-15 · 1240 MADISON AVENUE

The printed annual tax already deducts $385,389.36 in abatements and/or STAR.

The calculation deducts $93,600.00 in assessed-value exemptions before applying the tax rate.

Billable assessment on this statement
$20,741,220.00
Tax rate on this statement
12.4390%
Annual tax before abatements/STAR
$2,568,357.48
Monthly equivalent before abatements/STAR
$214,029.79

The before-abatement amount adds the printed deduction back to the annual tax, holding the assessment and rate unchanged. It does not predict benefit expiration, future taxes or a buyer’s eligibility.

DOF tax-purpose market value on this statement: $51,400,000.00.

Named benefits on the statement
Basic Star - School Tax Relief 1 unit $269.00
Enhanced Star - School Tax Relief 1 unit $647.00
Co-op/Condo Abatement 52 units $384,473.36

This covers the whole tax lot. Co-op building taxes cannot be added to an apartment’s maintenance or divided among its units.

Read official DOF tax bill ↗
How we calculate your annual taxes:
Billable assessed value: $20,741,220.00
minus exemptions: – $93,600.00
times the current tax rate: x 12.4390%
minus abatements and/or STAR: – $385,389.36
Annual property tax: $2,182,968.12

HOA, common charges and maintenance require documented building or unit evidence. Sales and DOB records do not establish these amounts. A zero property-tax bill does not establish zero PILOT or other ownership charges. Bills may change with tax rates or benefits; monthly figures are annual equivalents.

Look up this tax lot at DOF ↗

Public building financial filings

NY Attorney General offering plans and amendments can document budgets, financial statements, reserves and sponsor obligations. These records cover the development, including properties without active listings.

No exact offering-plan match has been collected here yet. Eligible condo and co-op properties are queued when viewed. Missing filings do not establish zero fees, assessments or debt.

Search the official NYAG offering-plan database ↗

Tax-benefit schedules, statement balances, penalties and declared capital work cover the identified tax lot. Condo billing-lot evidence is shown separately from apartment evidence.

DOB ECB penalties & reported balancesTax lot 1015010016

No supported financial amounts were returned in this source snapshot. This does not establish zero costs, no benefit, no debt or no penalties.

Balances retain the source’s reported status and observation date. An imposed penalty is not an additional amount to add to its balance due.

Latest refresh was partial; retained source evidence remains dated below.

Source updated 2026-10-14 · collected 2026-10-15.

Open official source ↗
DOF published abatements & termsTax lot 1015010016

Tax benefits & expiration

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
COOP · Published benefit begin date
Evidence

{"actabtpcyc": "0.00", "actabtpyr": "0.00", "appliedabt": "384473.33", "appseq": "23", "appstat": "A", "caseno": "2505", "extractdt": "2026-08-15T00:00:00.000", "parid": "1015010016", "period": "2Q", "rate_pct": "0.001750", "taxyr": "2027", "tccode": "COOP", "tcsubcode": "C1", "yearabtpct": "0.000000", "yrbegdt": "1996-07-01T00:00:00.000"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
1996-07-01As of 2026-08-15
FY2027 2Q
Published schedule · exact tax lot
COOP · Source applied abatement
Evidence

{"actabtpcyc": "0.00", "actabtpyr": "0.00", "appliedabt": "384473.33", "appseq": "23", "appstat": "A", "caseno": "2505", "extractdt": "2026-08-15T00:00:00.000", "parid": "1015010016", "period": "2Q", "rate_pct": "0.001750", "taxyr": "2027", "tccode": "COOP", "tcsubcode": "C1", "yearabtpct": "0.000000", "yrbegdt": "1996-07-01T00:00:00.000"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
$384,473.33As of 2026-08-15
FY2027 2Q
Source reported · exact tax lot
COOP · source eligibility / application status
Evidence

{"actabtpcyc": "0.00", "actabtpyr": "0.00", "appliedabt": "384473.33", "appseq": "23", "appstat": "A", "caseno": "2505", "extractdt": "2026-08-15T00:00:00.000", "parid": "1015010016", "period": "2Q", "rate_pct": "0.001750", "taxyr": "2027", "tccode": "COOP", "tcsubcode": "C1", "yearabtpct": "0.000000", "yrbegdt": "1996-07-01T00:00:00.000"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
appstat=AAs of 2026-08-15
FY2027 2Q
Source reported · exact tax lot

FY2027 2Q source abatement terms, dated 2026-08-15. Dates and amounts do not guarantee eligibility after purchase. Per-cycle amounts are not annualized; overlapping calculations are not summed.

Published benefit amounts and dates do not guarantee eligibility after a purchase. An end date alone does not establish the future tax bill; assessment, tax rate and other benefits may change.

Latest refresh was partial; retained source evidence remains dated below.

Source updated 2026-10-05 · collected 2026-10-09.

Open official source ↗
DOF final assessed-value exemptionsTax lot 1015010016

Tax benefits & expiration

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
17 E 89TH STREET TENANTS INC · Final actual exempt assessed value
Evidence

{"benftstart": "+0000", "bldg_class": "D4", "block": "1501", "boro": "1", "exmp_code": "1010", "exmp_code_suffix": "10101", "exmp_seq": "19", "exname": "17 E 89TH STREET TENANTS INC", "extractdt": "20260515", "finexmptot": "21600", "finexmptrn": "21600", "finexmptxbl": "21600", "fintaxclass": "2", "lot": "16", "no_years": "0", "nys_exmp_code": "41126", "parid": "1015010016", "period": "3", "pstatus": "A", "rectype": "1", "status": "A", "year": "2027"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
$21,600.00As of 2026-05-15
FY2027 final roll
Source reported · exact tax lot
17 E 89TH STREET TENANTS INC · Final exempt assessed value used for billing
Evidence

{"benftstart": "+0000", "bldg_class": "D4", "block": "1501", "boro": "1", "exmp_code": "1010", "exmp_code_suffix": "10101", "exmp_seq": "19", "exname": "17 E 89TH STREET TENANTS INC", "extractdt": "20260515", "finexmptot": "21600", "finexmptrn": "21600", "finexmptxbl": "21600", "fintaxclass": "2", "lot": "16", "no_years": "0", "nys_exmp_code": "41126", "parid": "1015010016", "period": "3", "pstatus": "A", "rectype": "1", "status": "A", "year": "2027"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
$21,600.00As of 2026-05-15
FY2027 final roll
Source reported · exact tax lot
17 E 89TH STREET TENANTS INC · Final actual exempt assessed value
Evidence

{"benftstart": "+0000", "bldg_class": "D4", "block": "1501", "boro": "1", "exmp_code": "1010", "exmp_code_suffix": "10101", "exmp_seq": "19", "exname": "17 E 89TH STREET TENANTS INC", "extractdt": "20260515", "finexmptot": "72000", "finexmptrn": "72000", "finexmptxbl": "72000", "fintaxclass": "2", "lot": "16", "no_years": "0", "nys_exmp_code": "41136", "parid": "1015010016", "period": "3", "pstatus": "A", "rectype": "1", "status": "A", "year": "2027"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
$72,000.00As of 2026-05-15
FY2027 final roll
Source reported · exact tax lot
17 E 89TH STREET TENANTS INC · Final exempt assessed value used for billing
Evidence

{"benftstart": "+0000", "bldg_class": "D4", "block": "1501", "boro": "1", "exmp_code": "1010", "exmp_code_suffix": "10101", "exmp_seq": "19", "exname": "17 E 89TH STREET TENANTS INC", "extractdt": "20260515", "finexmptot": "72000", "finexmptrn": "72000", "finexmptxbl": "72000", "fintaxclass": "2", "lot": "16", "no_years": "0", "nys_exmp_code": "41136", "parid": "1015010016", "period": "3", "pstatus": "A", "rectype": "1", "status": "A", "year": "2027"}

Tax benefit; do not add as a cost

Open official source ↗
$72,000.00As of 2026-05-15
FY2027 final roll
Source reported · exact tax lot

Final exemption values reduce assessed value; they are not cash savings or annual taxes. No expiration date inferred from a start year or duration.

Published benefit amounts and dates do not guarantee eligibility after a purchase. An end date alone does not establish the future tax bill; assessment, tax rate and other benefits may change.

Latest refresh was partial; retained source evidence remains dated below.

Source updated 2026-09-15 · collected 2026-10-09.

Open official source ↗
DOF statement balancesTax lot 1015010016

Public balances & charges

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
Outstanding charges
Evidence

Outstanding charges $0.00

Separate dated balance; do not add to annual costs

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot
New charges this billing period
Evidence

New charges $0.00

Separate dated balance; do not add to annual costs

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot
Statement amount due
Evidence

Amount Due 10/01/26: $0.00

Separate dated balance; do not add to annual costs

Due date: 2026-10-01

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-08-15
Source reported · exact tax lot

Latest refresh was partial; retained source evidence remains dated below.

Source updated 2026-08-15 · collected 2026-10-15.

Open official source ↗
DOB energy disclosureTax lot 1015010016

Penalties, energy & capital work

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
LL84 reported location-based emissions
Evidence

{"property_id": "3111539", "year_ending": "2024-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1015010016", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "676.19", "property_gfa_self_reported": "170158"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
676.19 tonnes CO2e2024
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported gross floor area
Evidence

{"property_id": "3111539", "year_ending": "2024-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1015010016", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "676.19", "property_gfa_self_reported": "170158"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
170,158 ft²2024
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported location-based emissions
Evidence

[{"property_id": "3111539", "year_ending": "2023-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1015010016", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "571.2", "property_gfa_self_reported": "235004"}, {"property_id": "3111539", "year_ending": "2023-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1-01501-0016", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "571.2", "property_gfa_self_reported": "235004"}]

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
571.2 tonnes CO2e2023
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported gross floor area
Evidence

[{"property_id": "3111539", "year_ending": "2023-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1015010016", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "571.2", "property_gfa_self_reported": "235004"}, {"property_id": "3111539", "year_ending": "2023-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1-01501-0016", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "571.2", "property_gfa_self_reported": "235004"}]

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
235,004 ft²2023
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported location-based emissions
Evidence

{"property_id": "3111539", "year_ending": "2022-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1-01501-0016", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "506", "property_gfa_self_reported": "235004"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
506 tonnes CO2e2022
Historical actual · reported property / campus
LL84 reported gross floor area
Evidence

{"property_id": "3111539", "year_ending": "2022-12-31T00:00:00.000", "nyc_borough_block_and_lot": "1-01501-0016", "number_of_buildings": "1", "metered_areas_energy": "Whole Property", "total_location_based_ghg": "506", "property_gfa_self_reported": "235004"}

Reported metric; not a fine

Open official source ↗
235,004 ft²2022
Historical actual · reported property / campus

Reported energy figures may cover several buildings or lots. They are not verified LL97 emissions, a penalty calculation, or this apartment’s utility bill.

Latest refresh was partial; retained source evidence remains dated below.

Source updated 2025-11-25 · collected 2026-10-15.

Open official source ↗
DOB declared construction workTax lot 1015010016

Penalties, energy & capital work

Reported itemValuePeriod & scope
Declared construction estimate · M01385593-S1-PMM#1
Evidence

Installation of temporary material hoist as per plan submitted. Work shall comply with 2022 building codes chapter 33. No change in use, egress and/or occupancy with this application.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$1,000.00As of 2026-10-13
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01416284-I1-GC#1
Evidence

INTERIOR RENOVATION IN APT 8E

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$190,000.00As of 2026-08-12
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01405220-I1-SC#1
Evidence

Installation of suspended scaffold for facade inspection/repair.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2026-06-02
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01369315-I1-GC#1
Evidence

INTERIOR RENOVATIONS OF APT. 2A AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$200,000.00As of 2026-04-30
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01369315-S1-MS#1
Evidence

THRU WALL AC UNIT AND AIR HANDLERS INSTALLATION FOR APT. 2A AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$80,000.00As of 2026-04-30
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01369315-S2-PL#1
Evidence

PLUMBING MODIFICATIONS FOR APT. 2A AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$28,000.00As of 2026-04-30
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01387145-I1-SF#1
Evidence

Installation of temporary supported scaffold per plan submitted. Work shall comply with 2022 building codes chapter 33. No change in use, egress and/or occupancy with this application.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$1.00As of 2026-04-22
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01385593-I1-SF#1
Evidence

Installation of temporary supported scaffold per plan submitted. Work shall comply with 2022 building codes chapter 33. No change in use, egress and/or occupancy with this application.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$1.00As of 2026-04-15
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01366320-I1-GC#1
Evidence

GENERAL CONSTRUCTION FOR EXTERIOR REPAIRS AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$1,421,000.00As of 2026-04-09
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01216281-S2-FN#1
Evidence

INSTALLATION OF PLYWOOD CONSTRUCTION FENCE AND ROOF PROTECTION AS PER PLANS IN COMPLAINCE WITH CHAPTER 33 OF NYC BC. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$2,000.00As of 2025-12-26
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01216281-S1-SF#1
Evidence

INSTALLATION OF PIPE SCAFFOLD AS PER PLANS IN COMPLIANCE WITH CHAPTER 33 OF NYCBC. NO CHANGE IN USE, AGRESS, OR OCCUPANCY UNDER THIS APPLICATION

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$2,000.00As of 2025-11-26
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01084832-I1-GC#1
Evidence

Exterior terrace reno including enlarging exist window to create door, repl pavers & stucco at PH West private terrace, modify existing railings, addtl trellis, replace awnings. Review requested under Prior 1968 code. No change to use, egress or occupncy

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$816,500.00As of 2025-05-14
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01216281-I1-SH#1
Evidence

INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED AS PER PLANS IN COMPLAINCE WITH CHAPTER 33 OF NYC BC. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$8,500.00As of 2025-05-14
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01084897-I1-ST#1
Evidence

Structural framing for new Awnings, and new Lintel for enlarged opening, as per plans filed herewith. No change to use, egress or occupancy.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$10,000.00As of 2025-04-02
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01133795-S1-PL#1
Evidence

REPLACED OR RELOCATED FIXTURES AND PIPING WILL BE INSTALLED AS SHOWN ON THESE PLANS. CONTRACTOR SHALL REMOVE EXISTING PLUMBING BRANCH PIPING AS NECESSARY BASED ON THESE PLANS.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$14,000.00As of 2024-12-05
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01133795-S2-MS#1
Evidence

NEW DUCTWORK, PIPING, AND EQUIPMENT WILL BE INSTALLED AS SHOWN ON THESE PLANS.CONTRACTOR SHALL REMOVE EXISTING EQUIPMENT AS NECESSARY BASED ON THESE PLANS.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$24,000.00As of 2024-12-04
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01133795-I1-GC#1
Evidence

renovation of existing apt# 3B with interior removal, new partitions and interior finishes; new openings to install a/c sleeves. no change in use, egress or occupancy.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$98,000.00As of 2024-11-22
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01103565-I1-PL#1
Evidence

PLUMBING WORKS AS SHOWN IN PLANS AT APT 5E ON THE 5TH FLOOR. NO CHANGE IN EGRESS, OCCUPANCY OR USE.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$25,000.00As of 2024-09-11
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01103543-I1-GC#1
Evidence

INTERIOR RENOVATION OF APT 5E ON THE 5TH FLOOR. SCOPE OF WORKS AS SHOWN IN PLANS. NO CHANGE IN EGRESS, OCCUPANCY OR USE.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$135,000.00As of 2024-09-09
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01089264-I1-SF#1
Evidence

INSTALLATION OF PIPE SCAFFOLDING AS PER PLANS. ALL EQUIPMENT SHALL COMPLY WITH CHAPTER # 33 OF THE 2022 CODE. NO CHANGE IN USE OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS UNDER THIS APPLICATION.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$5,000.00As of 2024-08-05
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01046564-S2-MS#1
Evidence

MH WORK FILED IN CONJUNCTION WITH DOB NOW GC AND PL. NO CHANGE TO USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$15,000.00As of 2024-06-11
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01046564-I1-GC#1
Evidence

INTERIOR RENOVATION IN APT 11A FILED IN CONJUNCTION WITH DOB NOW PL . NO CHANGE TO USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS,

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$191,080.00As of 2024-06-07
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01046564-S1-PL#1
Evidence

PLUMBING WORK FILED IN CONJUNCTION WITH DOB NOW GC. NO CHANGE TO USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS,

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$22,500.00As of 2024-06-07
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01025511-I1-SH#1
Evidence

INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED. NO CHANGE IN USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS. WORK SHALL COMPLY WITH CHAPTER 33 OF NYCC.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$1.00As of 2024-03-28
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01014978-I1-GC#1
Evidence

REMOVE MASONRY CHIMNEY CAPS, AND INSTALL NEW CHIMNEY LINER AND DRAFT INDUCERS FOR WOOD BURNING FIREPLACES. NO CHANGE TO USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$100,000.00As of 2024-03-27
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01019467-I1-SC#1
Evidence

Installation of suspended scaffold during facade Inspection/repair. SR23/2784

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2024-03-25
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01002957-S1-PL#1
Evidence

Refiling to legalize modification of plumbing fixtures and associated piping in apartment 2A . Work performed under BIS Job # 102212632.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$10,999.98As of 2024-03-01
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M01002957-I1-GC#1
Evidence

Refiling to legalize Interior renovation of apartment2A to include non load-bearing partitions. Work performed under BIS Job # 102212632.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$0.00As of 2024-02-28
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M00968475-S1-MS#1
Evidence

Direct replacement of existing condenser with related air handlers and mechanical duct/piping work at lobby and basement as per plans. No change to use, egress or occupancy.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$30,000.00As of 2024-01-09
Declared estimate · exact tax lot
Declared construction estimate · M00968475-I1-GC#1
Evidence

Renovation to lobby. Partition, finish and fixture work. No change to use, egress or occupancy.

Estimate; not an apartment assessment

Open official source ↗
$105,000.00As of 2023-12-13
Declared estimate · exact tax lot

Up to 30 most recent distinct filings from the past five years; this is not a complete capital-work inventory.

Declared job estimates are not actual spending or approved assessments. Repeated permit rows for the same filing are counted once; separate job filings may still describe related work.

Source publication date not provided.

Open official source ↗
Model annual LL97 emissions exposure

Enter verified LL97 emissions and the applicable annual limit. LL84 location-based emissions above are a different reported metric and are not automatically used here.

Enter both assumptions to calculate exposure.

Before exemptions, adjustments, offsets or penalty mitigation. This scenario does not establish an issued fine or an apartment charge.

Official DOB penalty guidance ↗

Active sale listings (1)

AddressNeighborhoodPrice$/ft²SqftBeds/Bathsvs compDOMRiskScore
17 EAST 89 STREET #3E
Manhattan · built 1925
Carnegie Hill$995K-0 ft²2 bd · 2 ba-59
8 DOBbedbug
10.2Source

Building activity

Open a record to read the full agency text.

Housing violations (HPD) 1

Bedbug reportClass AMar 15, 2023Violation dismissed

(A) § HMC:FILE ANNUAL BEDBUG REPORT IN ACCORDANCE WITH HPD RULE AS DESCRIBED ON THE BACK OF THIS NOTICE OF VIOLATION OR AS DESCRIBED ON HPDS WEBSITE, WWW.NYC.GOV\HPD, SEARCH BED BUGS.

HPD record 15786806

Work permits (DOB) 30

Protection and Mechanical MethodsOct 13, 2026Permit issued

Installation of temporary material hoist as per plan submitted. Work shall comply with 2022 building codes chapter 33. No change in use, egress and/or occupancy with this application.

DYNAMIX SCAFFOLD GROUP LL

Issued Oct 13, 2026

DOB filing M01385593-S1-PMM#1
General ConstructionAug 12, 2026Permit issued

INTERIOR RENOVATION IN APT 8E

ZENELI CONSTRUCTION CORP

Issued Sep 29, 2026

DOB filing M01416284-I1-GC#1
Suspended ScaffoldJun 2, 2026Permit issued

Installation of suspended scaffold for facade inspection/repair.

VEMA GROUP LLC

Issued Jun 2, 2026

DOB filing M01405220-I1-SC#1
Show 27 more records
Mechanical SystemsApr 30, 2026Permit issued

THRU WALL AC UNIT AND AIR HANDLERS INSTALLATION FOR APT. 2A AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.

BUILTECH ASSOCIATES INC

Issued Jun 2, 2026

DOB filing M01369315-S1-MS#1
PlumbingApr 30, 2026Permit issued

PLUMBING MODIFICATIONS FOR APT. 2A AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

AQUEDUCT MECHANICAL CORP

Issued Jun 8, 2026

DOB filing M01369315-S2-PL#1
General ConstructionApr 30, 2026Permit issued

INTERIOR RENOVATIONS OF APT. 2A AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE TO USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

BUILTECH ASSOCIATES INC

Issued Jun 2, 2026

DOB filing M01369315-I1-GC#1
Supported ScaffoldApr 22, 2026Permit issued

Installation of temporary supported scaffold per plan submitted. Work shall comply with 2022 building codes chapter 33. No change in use, egress and/or occupancy with this application.

VEMA GROUP LLC

Issued Apr 22, 2026

DOB filing M01387145-I1-SF#1
Supported ScaffoldApr 15, 2026Permit issued

Installation of temporary supported scaffold per plan submitted. Work shall comply with 2022 building codes chapter 33. No change in use, egress and/or occupancy with this application.

DYNAMIX SCAFFOLD GROUP LL

Issued Apr 15, 2026

DOB filing M01385593-I1-SF#1
General ConstructionApr 9, 2026Permit issued

GENERAL CONSTRUCTION FOR EXTERIOR REPAIRS AS PER PLANS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.

VEMA GROUP LLC

Issued Jun 5, 2026

DOB filing M01366320-I1-GC#1
Construction FenceDec 26, 2025Permit issued

INSTALLATION OF PLYWOOD CONSTRUCTION FENCE AND ROOF PROTECTION AS PER PLANS IN COMPLAINCE WITH CHAPTER 33 OF NYC BC. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.

DYNAMIX SCAFFOLD GROUP LL

Issued Dec 26, 2025

DOB filing M01216281-S2-FN#1
Supported ScaffoldNov 26, 2025Permit issued

INSTALLATION OF PIPE SCAFFOLD AS PER PLANS IN COMPLIANCE WITH CHAPTER 33 OF NYCBC. NO CHANGE IN USE, AGRESS, OR OCCUPANCY UNDER THIS APPLICATION

DYNAMIX SCAFFOLD GROUP LL

Issued Nov 26, 2025

DOB filing M01216281-S1-SF#1
Sidewalk ShedMay 14, 2025Permit issued

INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED AS PER PLANS IN COMPLAINCE WITH CHAPTER 33 OF NYC BC. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

DYNAMIX SCAFFOLD GROUP LL

Issued May 14, 2025

DOB filing M01216281-I1-SH#1
Sidewalk ShedMay 14, 2025Permit issued

INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED AS PER PLANS IN COMPLAINCE WITH CHAPTER 33 OF NYC BC. NO CHANGE IN USE, EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY

DYNAMIX SCAFFOLD GROUP LL

Issued Sep 28, 2026

DOB filing M01216281-I1-SH#3
General ConstructionMay 14, 2025Permit issued

Exterior terrace reno including enlarging exist window to create door, repl pavers & stucco at PH West private terrace, modify existing railings, addtl trellis, replace awnings. Review requested under Prior 1968 code. No change to use, egress or occupncy

IVAN DP CONSTRUCTION LLC

Issued Jun 22, 2026

DOB filing M01084832-I1-GC#3
General ConstructionMay 14, 2025Permit issued

Exterior terrace reno including enlarging exist window to create door, repl pavers & stucco at PH West private terrace, modify existing railings, addtl trellis, replace awnings. Review requested under Prior 1968 code. No change to use, egress or occupncy

IVAN DP CONSTRUCTION LLC

Issued Aug 18, 2025

DOB filing M01084832-I1-GC#1
General ConstructionMay 14, 2025Permit issued

Exterior terrace reno including enlarging exist window to create door, repl pavers & stucco at PH West private terrace, modify existing railings, addtl trellis, replace awnings. Review requested under Prior 1968 code. No change to use, egress or occupncy

IVAN DP CONSTRUCTION LLC

Issued Dec 16, 2025

DOB filing M01084832-I1-GC#2
StructuralApr 2, 2025Permit issued

Structural framing for new Awnings, and new Lintel for enlarged opening, as per plans filed herewith. No change to use, egress or occupancy.

IVAN DP CONSTRUCTION LLC

Issued Jun 22, 2026

DOB filing M01084897-I1-ST#3
StructuralApr 2, 2025Permit issued

Structural framing for new Awnings, and new Lintel for enlarged opening, as per plans filed herewith. No change to use, egress or occupancy.

IVAN DP CONSTRUCTION LLC

Issued Aug 18, 2025

DOB filing M01084897-I1-ST#1
StructuralApr 2, 2025Permit issued

Structural framing for new Awnings, and new Lintel for enlarged opening, as per plans filed herewith. No change to use, egress or occupancy.

IVAN DP CONSTRUCTION LLC

Issued Dec 16, 2025

DOB filing M01084897-I1-ST#2
PlumbingDec 5, 2024Signed-off

REPLACED OR RELOCATED FIXTURES AND PIPING WILL BE INSTALLED AS SHOWN ON THESE PLANS. CONTRACTOR SHALL REMOVE EXISTING PLUMBING BRANCH PIPING AS NECESSARY BASED ON THESE PLANS.

DOUBLE SOLUTIONS INC

Issued Jan 15, 2025

DOB filing M01133795-S1-PL#1
Mechanical SystemsDec 4, 2024Signed-off

NEW DUCTWORK, PIPING, AND EQUIPMENT WILL BE INSTALLED AS SHOWN ON THESE PLANS.CONTRACTOR SHALL REMOVE EXISTING EQUIPMENT AS NECESSARY BASED ON THESE PLANS.

S & T CONSTRUCTION INC

Issued Jan 14, 2025

DOB filing M01133795-S2-MS#1
General ConstructionNov 22, 2024Signed-off

renovation of existing apt# 3B with interior removal, new partitions and interior finishes; new openings to install a/c sleeves. no change in use, egress or occupancy.

S & T CONSTRUCTION INC

Issued Dec 4, 2024

DOB filing M01133795-I1-GC#1
PlumbingSep 11, 2024Signed-off

PLUMBING WORKS AS SHOWN IN PLANS AT APT 5E ON THE 5TH FLOOR. NO CHANGE IN EGRESS, OCCUPANCY OR USE.

T.N.T. PLBG & HTG, INC

Issued Oct 1, 2024

DOB filing M01103565-I1-PL#1
General ConstructionSep 9, 2024Signed-off

INTERIOR RENOVATION OF APT 5E ON THE 5TH FLOOR. SCOPE OF WORKS AS SHOWN IN PLANS. NO CHANGE IN EGRESS, OCCUPANCY OR USE.

BRUCI CONSTRUCTION SERVIC

Issued Sep 16, 2024

DOB filing M01103543-I1-GC#1
Supported ScaffoldAug 5, 2024Permit issued

INSTALLATION OF PIPE SCAFFOLDING AS PER PLANS. ALL EQUIPMENT SHALL COMPLY WITH CHAPTER # 33 OF THE 2022 CODE. NO CHANGE IN USE OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS UNDER THIS APPLICATION.

DYNAMIX SCAFFOLD GROUP LL

Issued Aug 5, 2024

DOB filing M01089264-I1-SF#1
Mechanical SystemsJun 11, 2024Signed-off

MH WORK FILED IN CONJUNCTION WITH DOB NOW GC AND PL. NO CHANGE TO USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS.

A-1 EXPERT INSTALLATION

Issued Sep 4, 2024

DOB filing M01046564-S2-MS#1
General ConstructionJun 7, 2024Signed-off

INTERIOR RENOVATION IN APT 11A FILED IN CONJUNCTION WITH DOB NOW PL . NO CHANGE TO USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS,

SGC CONTRACTING CORP

Issued Jun 12, 2024

DOB filing M01046564-I1-GC#1
PlumbingJun 7, 2024Signed-off

PLUMBING WORK FILED IN CONJUNCTION WITH DOB NOW GC. NO CHANGE TO USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS,

LS PLUMBING CORP

Issued Jun 20, 2024

DOB filing M01046564-S1-PL#1
Sidewalk ShedMar 28, 2024Permit issued

INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED. NO CHANGE IN USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS. WORK SHALL COMPLY WITH CHAPTER 33 OF NYCC.

DYNAMIX SCAFFOLD GROUP LL

Issued Mar 28, 2024

DOB filing M01025511-I1-SH#1
Mechanical SystemsMar 27, 2024Signed-off

REMOVE MASONRY CHIMNEY CAPS, AND INSTALL NEW CHIMNEY LINER AND DRAFT INDUCERS FOR WOOD BURNING FIREPLACES. NO CHANGE TO USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS.

AM BUILDING RESTORATION*

Issued Apr 29, 2025

DOB filing M01014978-I1-GC#2

Latest 30 records shown.

Building violations (DOB) 40

EVCAT5-NON-RESIDENTIAL ELEVATOR PERIODIC INSPECTION/TEST ELEVATORREQUIREDDec 17, 2021No disposition date supplied

FAILURE TO PERFORM CATEGORY 5 INSPECTION

DOB record 2564692
EVCAT5-NON-RESIDENTIAL ELEVATOR PERIODIC INSPECTION/TEST ELEVATORREQUIREDDec 17, 2021No disposition date supplied

FAILURE TO PERFORM CATEGORY 5 INSPECTION

DOB record 2564691
ACC1-(OTHER BLDGS TYPES) - ELEVATOR AFFIRMATION OF CORRECTION ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 6, 2019No disposition date supplied

VIO ISSUED TO ELEVATOR - FAIL TO CORRECT DEFECTS ON 2017 CAT 1 INSP/TST TST

DOB record 2386346
Show 37 more records
ACC1-(OTHER BLDGS TYPES) - ELEVATOR AFFIRMATION OF CORRECTION ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 6, 2019No disposition date supplied

VIO ISSUED TO ELEVATOR - FAIL TO CORRECT DEFECTS ON 2017 CAT 1 INSP/TST TST

DOB record 2386348
ACC1-(OTHER BLDGS TYPES) - ELEVATOR AFFIRMATION OF CORRECTION ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 6, 2019No disposition date supplied

VIO ISSUED TO ELEVATOR - FAIL TO CORRECT DEFECTS ON 2017 CAT 1 INSP/TST TST

DOB record 2386347
ACC1-(OTHER BLDGS TYPES) - ELEVATOR AFFIRMATION OF CORRECTION ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 6, 2019No disposition date supplied

VIO ISSUED TO ELEVATOR - FAIL TO CORRECT DEFECTS ON 2017 CAT 1 INSP/TST TST

DOB record 2386345
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 18, 2018Disposition recorded Apr 28, 2020

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 2314245
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 18, 2018Disposition recorded Apr 28, 2020

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 2314246
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 18, 2018Disposition recorded Apr 28, 2020

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 2457585
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 18, 2018Disposition recorded Apr 28, 2020

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 2457587
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDOct 14, 2015Disposition recorded Apr 7, 2017

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 2170967
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDOct 14, 2015Disposition recorded Apr 7, 2017

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 2021981
LANDMK-LANDMARK NONEOct 9, 2015Disposition recorded Oct 7, 2024

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 914353
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 29, 2014Disposition recorded Jul 9, 2015

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1900760
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 29, 2014Disposition recorded Jul 9, 2015

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1900762
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 29, 2014Disposition recorded Jul 9, 2015

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1900761
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 26, 2014Disposition recorded Jul 9, 2015

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1982653
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDOct 4, 2012Disposition recorded Jul 31, 2013

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1714014
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDOct 4, 2012Disposition recorded Jul 31, 2013

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1714017
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDOct 4, 2012Disposition recorded Jul 31, 2013

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1784070
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDOct 4, 2012Disposition recorded Jul 31, 2013

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1714015
LANDMK-LANDMARK NONEJul 30, 2012Disposition recorded Oct 5, 2012

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1691406
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDAug 17, 2011Disposition recorded Jul 31, 2013

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1784069
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDAug 17, 2011Disposition recorded Jul 31, 2013

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1784072
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDAug 17, 2011Disposition recorded Jul 31, 2013

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1597343
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDAug 17, 2011Disposition recorded Jul 31, 2013

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1597342
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 23, 2010Disposition recorded Mar 24, 2011

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1522666
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDMar 24, 2010No disposition date supplied

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1461328
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDMar 24, 2010No disposition date supplied

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1461329
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDNov 10, 2009Disposition recorded Mar 24, 2011

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1563189
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDNov 5, 2009Disposition recorded Mar 24, 2011

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1442049
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDNov 5, 2009Disposition recorded Mar 24, 2011

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1442055
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDNov 5, 2009Disposition recorded Jan 10, 2011

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1442047
LANDMK-LANDMARK NONEAug 15, 2008Disposition recorded Oct 22, 2009

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1338173
LANDMK-LANDMARK NONEJun 11, 2008Disposition recorded May 5, 2015

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 354237
LL1198-LOCAL LAW 11/98 - FACADE FACADE OPTIONALNov 30, 2007Disposition recorded Apr 10, 2023

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1268088
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 4, 2007Disposition recorded Mar 24, 2011

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1236376
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 4, 2007Disposition recorded Mar 24, 2011

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1236378
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 4, 2007Disposition recorded Mar 24, 2011

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1563187
E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIREDSep 4, 2007Disposition recorded Mar 24, 2011

Agency description not supplied.

DOB record 1236374

Latest 40 records shown.

Transaction history · 0 deeds

Recorded consideration. A $0 deed is not a sale price.

No recorded transactions for this BBL yet.

More buildings in Carnegie Hill

Sources, coverage & freshness

Sources & freshness

Research contract nyc_property_research.v1 · snapshot Oct 24, 2026

Stable property ID: nyc:bbl:1015010016

This identifier represents an NYC tax lot. Condo and co-op apartment identity must be resolved separately.

Tax lot and building facts

NYC Department of City Planning (PLUTO)

completed
1 tax-lot record in the current corpus · latest record Oct 18, 2026

Pipeline completed Oct 18, 2026

The current PLUTO pipeline is configured for Manhattan and Brooklyn.

PLUTO describes the tax lot and buildings, not legal ownership of an individual apartment.

Marketed sale listings

StreetEasy, observed by CurbScoop

completed
1 active sale listing in the current corpus · latest record Apr 15, 2026

Pipeline completed Aug 31, 2026

Retired source: collection stopped on 2026-08-31, so these are the last Manhattan and Brooklyn listings observed, not the current market.

Listing observations describe marketed state as of 2026-08-31 at the latest and are not proof of a closing or exhaustive market coverage.

Recorded transfers

NYC Department of Finance, Office of the City Register (ACRIS)

completed
0 recorded deeds in the current corpus

Pipeline completed Oct 23, 2026

Deed document types associated with this BBL in the current CurbScoop corpus.

Recording can lag a transaction, and a deed with no stated consideration is not evidence of a market sale.

DOB permits

NYC Department of Buildings via NYC Open Data

completed
245 permits in the current corpus · latest record Oct 13, 2026

Pipeline completed Oct 23, 2026

The current DOB permit pipeline is configured for Manhattan and Brooklyn.

A filing or permit does not prove that work was completed or that all work at the property was filed.

HPD violations

NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development via NYC Open Data

completed
1 violation in the current corpus · latest record Mar 20, 2023

Pipeline completed Oct 23, 2026

The current HPD violation pipeline is configured for Manhattan and Brooklyn.

Status and correction timing come from the published agency record and may change after CurbScoop observes it.

DOB violations

NYC Department of Buildings via NYC Open Data

completed
58 violations in the current corpus · latest record Sep 25, 2025

Pipeline completed Oct 23, 2026

The current DOB violation pipeline is configured for Manhattan and Brooklyn.

Absence from the current corpus is not proof that a building has no regulatory issue.

Counts and dates describe the current CurbScoop corpus. They are not a guarantee of exhaustive agency or listing coverage.

How to read these records

Deed amounts are recorded consideration, not asking prices or a unit valuation. A blank record is not proof that an issue does not exist.

Recorded salesComparable salesBuilding identifiers